From good to great: what we learned building our own management development programme

Published

Author

Read time
5 mins

Over the past year, we’ve tried to close the manager capability gap in our own business, with Catalyst, our management development programme at Ciphr. In this blog post, I’ll share what we did, what I’d do differently, and what I think transfers to other organisations.

Why training fades without confidence

We started from a point I’ve covered in my last two blog posts on why your people polices aren’t developing leadership and management skills and why managers are struggling and how to help them to improve: most management training is perfectly good. The content is sound, the facilitators are skilled, the feedback is positive. Then managers go back to their desks and very little changes.

Part of that is the forgetting curve: knowledge drains away without reinforcement. But the bigger issue, I think, is confidence. A manager can remember a model perfectly and still not use it, because recalling a framework in a training room and applying it with someone who is upset or defensive in the moment are different things.

So rather than asking what our managers needed to know, we asked what we wanted them to still be doing 18 months later.

What we built

We launched Catalyst in July 2025 for around 45 people managers. The first thing we did wasn’t training at all. We wrote down what good looks like, in a manager playbook built around five plays: build a dream team, raise the bar, create a safe space, bring the magic, and nail the everyday.

Every manager then completed a skills analysis against those plays, a 180 combining their own view with their line manager’s, using the in-app functionality in our own Ciphr learning management system (LMS). That gave each person a clear picture of their strengths and gaps, and a development conversation to go with it, with direct links to relevant eLearning.

From there, we built the programme for the long haul: structured reviews at six and 12 months, optional monthly manager summits around the five plays, an intranet toolkit that mirrors the playbook, a managers’ community, and manager surgeries. The 180 repeats at 12 months, so people can see how far they’ve come.

What I’d do differently

I don’t think case studies are useful without honesty, so here are four reflections.

Firstly, our timescales were too tight. We set a deadline for the skills analysis and had to extend it, because managers are busy and we underestimated the effort involved in the line manager ratings. Give people longer than feels necessary.

Secondly, we didn’t use our senior leaders well enough. We had strong sponsorship at launch, with our CEO introducing the programme, but we treated that as the job done. We should have kept asking our leadership team to carry the message: referencing the standards in their own conversations, asking their teams how their reviews went, and being seen to model the behaviours we were asking of everyone else. When a programme is owned only by the people team, it’s seen as a people team initiative.

Thirdly, we put a lot of energy into the launch and not enough, initially, into the sustain. Getting 45 managers through the programme was a project, but keeping them developing afterwards needs an operating model, and more effort, not less.

And finally, we created a single point of failure. One highly capable, super-motivated L&D expert carried the programme, and when they left the business, we were exposed. What had been a labour of love for one person became an edge-of-desk responsibility for the rest of the team, and we’ve had to work hard to keep it going.

Four things that transfer to any management development programme

Your context will be different, but I think four principles travel well.

  1. Define the standard before you design the learning. If you can’t write down what good looks like, you can’t develop anyone towards it or measure progress. Our playbook was the hardest part to create and gave us the biggest return

  2. Involve the manager’s manager. The 180 did something a self-assessment never could. It prompted a real conversation about strengths and gaps between two people who then had to work on them together

  3. Separate content from practice. Send the knowledge ahead in short pieces people can absorb around their job, and save precious face-to-face time for scenarios, role-play and peer learning

  4. Design month nine before you design the launch. If you can’t describe what happens nine months in, the programme will fade, however good the launch was

Where structured learning stops

Structured learning is the foundation of any management development programme. It gives managers a shared language, a common standard and knowledge you can hold them to. But it’s brilliant at the moment of learning and much less present at the moment of need.

The real test comes at half past eight on a Monday morning, when a manager is about to have a conversation they’ve been dreading. That’s the gap I believe AI-powered coaching like MyTeamBuilder can fill: support that’s there when the manager needs it, reinforcing the standards they’ve learned and helping them apply those standards to the person in front of them.

See what month nine could look like

Month nine is where most programmes fade, and it’s where support at the moment of need matters most. MyTeamBuilder gives managers AI-powered coaching before a difficult conversation, shaped by your own policies and by the person they’re about to speak to. If you’re planning the sustain phase of your own management development programme, book a demo to see how it works.

About the author

 Karen Lough is director of people at Ciphr. She has nearly 20 years’ experience in learning and development and leading key transformation projects, including capability and behavioural frameworks, leadership development and performance management.